The cockpit suddenly went quiet. The pilot called air traffic control to request an immediate emergency landing, but it was too late.
With no thrust and only a few hundred feet of altitude, Capt. Chesley (Sully) Sullenberger decided his only option was to ditch US Airways flight 1549 into the Hudson River.
As it turned out, he greased that landing back on Jan. 15, 2009, but there was no rulebook for landing an Airbus A320 on the Hudson River. Nor did he get to practice a few times with an empty plane to get the hang of it. He had 155 lives in his hands and one shot to get it right.
In a lot of ways, I think selling a business is a little like trying to land a passenger jet on a river: you’ve probably never done it before, you don’t get to practice, and there’s a lot riding on the outcome.
To help give you a sense of what to expect from the process of selling your business, I asked Brad Bottoset, an eleven-year veteran of selling companies, to answer some common questions I get from readers….
Warrillow: Can you explain the role of seller financing in selling a business? How common is it? How exactly does it work in layman’s terms?
Bottoset: It is estimated that 80 to 85% of all business transactions carry seller financing. Why? Many potential buyers don’t have the capital or lender resources to pay cash. Even if they do, they often want to leverage it into buying a larger business with greater cash flow. Buyers interpret the seller’s insistence on all cash as a lack of confidence in the business, the buyer’s chance to succeed, or both. Of course, every transaction is different, but typically a seller should expect somewhere around one year’s cash flow as the down payment. Just like banks use formulas to determine what someone can afford as a mortgage on a home, knowledgeable business brokers use formulas too – which generally point to the Note being paid off in 5 to 7 years.
Warrillow: Isn’t the whole point of selling your business to get liquid? Why would you lend someone the money to buy your business? If you’re not getting the cash upfront, why not just hold on to the business?
Bottoset: For most sellers, getting all cash upfront is their preferred route. However, it may not be possible. And there are a number of positives with seller financing:
- Making the terms attractive and attainable increases the pool of qualified buyers;
- Offering terms will command a higher price (buyers paying cash often demand a discount);
- Tax consequences can be advantageous. Instead of being taxed in the year that the sale occurs, the seller’s capital gain is taxed over the life of the Note;
- With interest rates currently at their lowest in years, sellers can get a much higher rate (6%) than they can get from any financial institution.
Warrillow: What is the typical interest rate of a seller-financed deal these days?
Bottoset: Six percent.
Warrillow: I know one of the steps in getting a business ready for sale involves dressing up the Profit & Loss statement to show as much profit as possible. Can you give me some examples of things business owners often overlook?
Bottoset: When determining the value of a business, one of the key steps is understanding what levels of discretionary, non-business expenses the current owner is expensing through the business. There are many standard types of “add backs” such as the owner’s car expenses, personal health insurance, etc…. However, we also have seen a number of examples of creative bookkeeping, such as trips to Europe classified as a “market research” expense, owner divorces identified as “legal fees,” etc. One common area that is often overlooked is when the business owner also owns the facility out of which the business operates. Depending on the situation, they may be charging themselves fair market value (FVM) rent, or they may not. If they are charging the business more than FMV, a positive add back would be appropriate. If they are charging themselves less, a negative add back must be accounted for.
Warrillow: You use “social desirability” as one of the factors that can drive up, or down, the value of a business. What do you mean by “social desirability,” and can you give some examples of either desirable or undesirable businesses? How big an impact is social desirability on the value of a business, and can you give an example?
Bottoset: I can’t say I’ve come across a lot of businesses that will generate a significant premium, but I do know of a few that have been adversely affected by a lack of social desirability. For instance, in our portfolio, we have a national trucking company that transports live animals for medical research. We’ve had a number of qualified buyers (both from within the transportation industry and from outside) look at the business but they have shied away because of perceived issues with animal rights organizations like PETA.
Warrillow: What other factors drive up, or down, the value of a business? Can you give a real life example?
Bottoset: The basic value drivers are management depth, proprietary product, customer diversity, etc…. Unfortunately, many clients don’t fully understand some of these principles. A few months ago, we had a manufacturing client approach us to find a buyer for his business. He was particularly proud of two aspects of his business: firstly, that all decisions go through his office as he is the point of contact with the clients; and secondly, in preparing the business for sale, he had whittled down the client base from 20 to two clients. In his eyes, the new buyer was going to have 18 less headaches and personalities to deal with. Yikes on two counts! Unfortunately, this is a true story!
Warrillow: Can you explain the difference between an asset sale and a share sale? Why does it matter to business owners?
Bottoset: In an asset sale, the buyer essentially acquires selected company assets, consisting of the company’s equipment, inventory and “goodwill.” In a stock purchase, when purchasing the company’s stock, they are acquiring all of the company’s assets, including its cash and accounts receivable, and are assuming responsibility to pay off the company’s debts (i.e., accounts payable) while assuming all “off the book” liabilities (i.e., pending or future lawsuits). Buyers typically prefer to buy the assets of a company for two reasons. Firstly, they are able to re-depreciate the value of the fixed assets and therefore acquire a larger depreciation tax shelter. Secondly, they are not responsible for any “off the book” liabilities (i.e., lawsuits). Most business transactions are completed as asset sales.
I’ve asked Brad Bottoset to spend an hour with the 20 people coming to my Built to Sell workshop on January 16 & 17, 2012. There are three spots available – grab one here.
(photo Eric Thayer / Reuters)








